When employers review their workplace drug and alcohol testing programs, the conversation can quickly turn to the available options. Should we use a different testing method? Test for additional substances? Change when or how testing takes place? Change who does the testing and/or specimen collections?
Those are reasonable questions. But before exploring the options, I encourage employers to ask a more fundamental one: What are we trying to accomplish?
A change in testing methods may be worthwhile. It may offer practical advantages or provide information better suited to a particular workplace concern. But changing the test itself does not necessarily make the overall program more effective.
Start with the workplace concern
Perhaps supervisors are uncertain about how to respond when they believe someone may not be fit for duty, which may or may not be related to substance use. Perhaps an employer is reviewing its approach following an incident. Or perhaps the existing program has been in place for years, and no one has recently considered whether it is working as intended.
Each situation calls for a clear understanding of the problem before decisions about testing. Otherwise, it’s easy to focus on the mechanics of a test without considering what role the result is expected to play.
Know what the result can, and cannot, tell you
Drug and alcohol testing can provide useful information, but different approaches have different purposes and limitations. A test result does not, by itself, answer every question about safety risk, fitness for duty or the appropriate workplace response. It certainly does not prove impairment.
Employers also need to consider what happens after the result. Who will interpret the information appropriately? What established process guides the next decision? How will the employee be treated fairly and consistently?
Keep the larger goal in view
The goal is to support safe work and healthy people. Testing is only one part of an effective Workplace Drug & Alcohol Program, so changing testing procedures won’t necessarily improve the program overall.
Before investing in a new testing approach, ask whether it will address the actual workplace concern and whether the rest of the program is ready to use the information it provides effectively.
A better testing decision begins with a better question. What do we need to know, why do we need to know it, and what will we do next?
If you’re reviewing your workplace drug and alcohol testing program, book a call with me to discuss what you want it to accomplish.